5 September

1550 death of Tribolo
1550 Philibert de l'Orme was made a canon of Notre Dame (Paris).

1800 birth of Michael Gottlieb Bindesböll
1813 death of James Wyatt
1838 death of Charles Percier
1869 foundation stone for Neuschwanstein laid

Campo Marzio - the triumphal way
1997.09.05     e2749a e2864 e2899 e3037 e3044 e3078a 3122z 3321b 3788 5318s 5397g

Cathedral of Tyre - answers
2001.09.05 07:54     8210g

MVRDV masterplan in Tirana
2008.09.05 08:43     3333b 3747j 3767e 3794c 3899g 4706b 5050 5051
2008.09.05 09:38     3333b 3749p 3770w 3794d
2008.09.05 09:53     3333b 3749p 3794d 3899g

New Haven visit
2008.09.05 09:00     3333b

Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
2014.09.05 09:33     3765f 3775v
2014.09.05 10:11     3775v
2014.09.05 11:30     3775v 4014l
2014.09.05 16:06
2014.09.05 16:35     3773p 4614b
2014.09.05 19.01
2014.09.05 19:29
2014.09.05 20:10

read last night--delivery of content
2021.09.05 13:16     3736ad 3765f

read last night--no such erasures, exclusions, or omissions are possible
2021.09.05 20:21     3775ab

Estudio Entresitio . MGP Arquitectos   Museo Nacional de la Memoria   Bogotá

MVRDV   Valley   Amsterdam

Mecanoo   North Station Urban Design   Shenzhen

2008.09.05 08:43
MVRDV masterplan in Tirana
It's not geo-mimicry, it's jury-mimicry!

"Hey, let's design a reenactment of this painting."
"Yeah, we'll do it like abstractly, and when other architects see the scheme they'll start reenacting a design jury."
--excerpt from "Scalping Double Theater Tickets" in The Further Adventures of the Broke Baroque Style.

2008.09.05 09:38
MVRDV masterplan in Tirana
the next design...

2008.09.05 09:53
MVRDV masterplan in Tirana
"In September 2001, while seeing a display of quartz crystals (each labeled as to its geographic origin) compiled over 100 years ago, I thought it would be cool if the buildings of any global location started to match the formations of the local quartz. It was after seeing Harz Mountain quartz that the idea crystalized."
2004.10.05 14:54
--excerpt from "Ur-Geo-Mimicry" in Architektur von Vorläufer

10090501 Museum of Architecture scan plan with other museum plans   2245i02
10090502 Michelangelo's fortification sketches   2400i01

12090501 Levy Memorial Playground plan   218ai00

2014.09.05 09:33
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
The "the pursuit of reductionist aesthetics" in Roman Catholic church architecture is more due to the suggestions of the Second Vatican Council than to "architects [being] uncomfortable with symbolic content and figurative art." Look carefully at the dates of the "uninspired" churches and you'll more likely find them from the mid-1960s onward. Plus there is the whole issue of cost versus budget--the money to build large/elaborate churches just isn't there anymore, along with the fact that the cost of building large/elaborate churches rose exponentially. The notion that architects and their modernist education is the blame for uninspired churches is simplistic at best.

2014.09.05 16:06
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
Interestingly, the Roman Catholic Church I grew up within was very much a deterministic clockwork machine (for collecting tax-free dollars, among other things).

2014.09.05 19.01
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
I walk in the woods for about an hour almost daily year-round. I've been doing it for almost three years now, and my appreciation of the beauty of the woods at this point in my life far surpasses anything I may have felt as a child. That being said, I've never liked the Fay Jones chapel, and it never occurred to me that that space was evocative of the woods, I think because the real beauty of the woods stems not from 'order' rather from the magnitude of its disorder. In the winter, when the trees are bare of leaves and there's not much sun in the sky, sometimes all you see is a nimiety of lines, I'm guessing thousands upon thousands of disordered lines seen all at once, and, what's fascinating is that among this great multitude and disorder you're still able pick out any individual crocked line. I've often wondered, "Am I seeing over a million different lines right now?" To me (and I rarely use the word because it has become virtually meaningless due to abuse) that's actually awesome.
As I already said, the Fay Jones chapel looks excessive[ly ordered] and un-necessarily busy.

2014.09.05 19:29
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
EKE, my current understanding of the beauty of the woods stems entirely from my almost daily experience of the woods. It's just me giving some thought to what I actually see. However, I now also have reason to believe that the woods themselves harbor the beauty, well independent of any cultural 'teaching'. Every so often a friend (and fellow architect) joins me on my walks--so far I've taken him on all the different trails and different (parts of the) parks I go through. And on several occasions he will express a sensation about some particular spot that is identical to the sensation that I felt when I first experienced the same spot. The beauty is like inherently there whether anyone appreciates or not.

2014.09.05 20:10
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
It wasn't that we both found the same spots beautiful, it was that the same spots elicited identical sensations, and not just visuals like a sudden vista, but also sounds (of the creek) and "feelings" one got in certain spots. For example, there is a spot on the path along the creek were the water babbling strikes one more distinctly than all the other points along the creek. I noticed it after passing it a few times and was very surprised several months latter when my friend immediately commented on the sound at the very same spot. I didn't mention anything to my friend at the time, but on all my subsequent walks there I wondered about what made the sound special there, so one day I decided to just stand there and figure it out. It turns out that the babbling sound(s) there are created by the water running over two separate lines of rocks across the creek with one line being about 20 yards downstream from the other. Thus, there is this 15 foot stretch along the foot path where you hear the babbling(s) in a kind of stereo. If you take your time and concentrate you can make out each distinct babbling emanating from each line of rocks, but, regardless, you cannot help but still hear them both at the same time.

14090501 Lauf Haus der Kunst plan 22002 NNTC/Ottopia context   2306i13

2014.09.05 10:11
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
Object lesson or (very short) period piece?

For the Philadelphia church of Saint Francis de Sales, Venturi & Rauch changed the focus from the original neo-Byzantine sanctuary to a new-liturgy arrangement by means of a kind of electric demolition (1968). As if they were making an editor's deletion on the statement of the original sanctuary, they literally drew a line through the old altar and its reredos, editing it out. That line is a cold cathode tube of light suspended on piano wire, ten feet above the church floor, following the gentle curve of the apse. The tube cancels out the old altar with the intensity of its electric light; yet the original statement can still be seen behind, as if in the distance.
This demolition is doubly literary in that, it is analogous to a deletion rather than being an actual one, and second, it alludes to literary or editorial procedures. In the "electric age" this is a pivotal example of the architecture of allusion. In addition, the result is a milestone of church art and a new church image. The decision to preserve the old altar was made by the architects because they felt that its jewel-encrusted craftsmanship should be retained as an expression of the church's historical continuity. That was a decision unlike the wiping away of historical ornamentation that was indulged in by the purgative "clean" designers of the 1950s. The architects also used the line of electric demolition to focus on the new furnishings of the new sanctuary. "The shape of the magic line cathode," as Venturi called it, is not the only element that defines the new sanctuary, of course, but it is the most supermannerist of the church's innovations. As other furnishings, the congregation required a lectern and a priest's chair in addition to the freestanding altar table. To match the new liturgy, the architects provided a completely new image for these furnishings. Three shiny objects of white plexiglass and white vinyl, with accents of yellow vinyl and plexiglass, are set amid the neo-Byzantine surroundings. The translucent soft-curved hard plastic panels and the soft hard-edged, wet-looking vinyl in a church look like Claes Oldenburg gone pious. The architects knew, as Venturi said, that they "could not get harmony through similitude" in these new furnishings because they could not afford, much less surpass, the richness of materials--marbles, jewels, and mosaics--that had been possible when the church was built in 1907. As a consequence, they sought "harmony through contrast." The plexiglass is similar to, yet contrasts with, the marble; the soft furniture contrasts with the usual church furniture yet has harmonious forms.
Unfortunately, that design image was too totally new for a large segment of the congregation of Saint Francis de Sales. Seven months after installation, "electric demolition" took on a double and sadder meaning when the congregation removed the cathode-tube light to a storage room. They thereby blindly demolished the architect's imaginatively allusive scheme, leaving only the acrylic and vinyl furniture intact.
C. Ray Smith, Supermannerism: New Attitudes in Post-Modern Architecture (New York: E. P. Dutton, 1977), pp. 256-8.

Virtual Museum 007

15090501   Estudio Entresitio . MGP Arquitectos   Museo Nacional de la Memoria   Bogotá

17090501   MVRDV   Valley   Amsterdam
17090502   Mecanoo   North Station Urban Design   Shenzhen

19090501   Weiss House plan elevation   216hi04
19090502   Yale Art Gallery plan work   217vi03

2014.09.05 11:30
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
The restoration design was quite a unique interpretation of the precepts of the Second Vatican Council. Like the neon line, however, a segment of Church followers were not happy with the Second Vatican Council's 'new' Church either.
The furniture, especially the lectern (and here D might well agree since I'm sure she and I both saw and closely examined the piece), has a very ethereal quality--albeit basically white Plexiglas, the lectern has an almost 'supernatural' gravity while at the same time an almost anti-gravity lightness, not unlike the quality most often attributed to a deity.

2014.09.05 16:35
Why Modern Architecture Struggles to Inspire Catholics
The left church I find more contemplative, catacomb-esque even. The right church I find excessive and un-necessarily busy.

In the future, interpretations of the Third Vatican Council will be famous for fifteen minutes.




Quondam © 2021.09.05